Stop chasing the 2%. Start serving the abandoned 98%


Introduction

Dove figured out something brilliant in 2004.

They weaponized a devastating statistic against their entire industry.

Only 2% of women considered themselves beautiful. The beauty industry was selling to 98% of people who felt excluded by their own advertising.

Smart CMOs saw the opportunity immediately.

While competitors chased the same 2% with perfect models, Dove claimed the abandoned 98%.

The result?

Sales doubled from $2.5 billion to $4 billion in one decade.

Research Intelligence

45 minutes dedicated multi-AI research

✅ 75 sources across 3 AIs

✅ 33 primary company sources

✅ Global coverage across North America, Europe, Asia-Pacific

✅ 12 cross-industry patterns confirmed

THE STRATEGIC CHOICE

Here's what worked.

Dove inverted their entire category's core assumption.

While every competitor sold aspiration, Dove sold acceptance.

While others promoted impossible standards, Dove questioned those standards.

The reality is simple.

Beauty brands were alienating their own customers.

Dove's research proved 98% of women felt excluded by traditional beauty advertising.

No major brand was addressing this massive disconnect.

The campaign launched with interactive billboards asking "Wrinkled or Wonderful?"

People could vote via SMS. Results displayed in real-time.

Business Impact:

The campaign generated $4 billion in sales from $2.5 billion over ten years. That's 60% revenue growth in a mature category.

(Just a note: Sales figures represent total campaign period performance; incremental sales attribution and baseline comparison data not publicly disclosed by Unilever.

For strategic planning, consider this as campaign correlation rather than confirmed causation.)

Strategic Efficiency:

Dove achieved 30x return on earned media.

For every dollar spent on ads, they earned $30 in free exposure.

(Another intelligence note here: ROI calculations represent total campaign period performance; baseline sales adjustments and attribution methodology not publicly disclosed by Unilever.

For strategic planning, this is more correlation again. Just being honest.)

video preview

Check out this 2 min Ad using 50,000 syringes representing 50,000 teens in Canada who used some sort of beauty injection.

This is the "purpose" in "purpose-driven inversion Category" we're speaking to here.

Innovation Validation:

Dove's firming cream sales doubled in month one.

Then grew 700% in six months. Market share jumped from 1% to 6% in that category.

This wasn't just advertising. It was market research happening in public.

Competitors couldn't easily copy this approach.

How do you sell anti-wrinkle cream while celebrating wrinkles?

Dove sold cleansing and moisturizing products.

They could celebrate natural beauty without contradicting their product promises.

THE TRANSFERABLE PATTERN

"Purpose-Driven Category Inversion"

This works because it transforms marketing from persuasion to advocacy.

And why does that work? Because when you side with deeply held values, people side with your cause.

Smart CMOs recognize the pattern. Find your industry's fundamental dishonesty. Challenge it publicly with authentic commitment.

What this means for you: Look for the lie your category tells customers. Build your brand by telling the truth instead.

The pattern requires three elements. Irrefutable consumer research exposing the disconnect.

Operational commitment beyond just advertising. Sustained platform thinking over campaign cycles.

Dove didn't run a campaign. They started a movement.

The Self-Esteem Project reached 100 million youth globally.

That's business transformation, not marketing tactics.

WHERE THIS PATTERN WINS

Here's where else this works:

Always #LikeAGirl:

video preview

I'm not going to lie. This one made me tear up a bit.

Challenged gender stereotypes in feminine care. Generated 75-90 million video views and measurable sales increases for P&G.

Nike Dream Crazy:

video preview

Took political stance against industry norm of staying apolitical. Added estimated $6 billion in brand value despite controversy.

Burger King Moldy Whopper:

video preview

Take a look at this 2 min video. The advertising and impact are simply genius. It deserves a whole another newsletter on!

Showed their burger decaying over 34 days to prove no artificial preservatives. Generated 8 billion media impressions and 14% sales increase (WPP case study).

STRATEGIC DURABILITY

Bottom line for you:

This pattern works when you have the courage to commit.

The approach succeeds during cultural tension periods. When consumers feel disconnected from industry messaging.

Market conditions favor authentic positioning now. Social media amplifies inauthentic brand behavior faster than ever.

If you'd like to see my advice with 4 questions to consider before moving on this pattern go to my loom video here:

MULTI-LLM INSIGHT CALLOUT:

All three AI models spotted the same core insight. Dove succeeded by claiming abandoned market territory.

The split was interesting.

ChatGPT highlighted technical innovation in interactive billboards.

Claude focused on long-term platform building.

Gemini emphasized competitor inability to respond authentically.

PS - If you're looking for a deep dive...

  • See the raw multi-AI research and competitive analysis frameworks.
  • Get implementation playbooks that executives use to outmaneuver bigger competitors.
  • 6 Min Video Commentary and presentation - where I share my own thoughts on this trend
  • [Bonus] - a fully ready Client Strategy Presentation Deck on this topic (free download)

[Access the Strategic Deep-Dive →] Tons of reading + video commentary

Your Passionate Marketing Research Assistant

Matt Heyn
Point of Contact & Copywriter at VyB

When you're ready here are 2 ways I can help you:

  1. Main service for CMOs and Marketing Directors:

If you’re tired of:

  • Managing 5 vendors when what you really need is an All-in-One Turn-Key Agency

Grab one of the remaining spots now for a free discovery call.

If you don't get 3 actionable insights on your brand story or business, I'll connect you with another agency that can.

No pitching, no sales call. Just auditing your business and providing 3 insights.

2. Need Inspiration?

For weekly LinkedIn videos and posts on copywriting and marketing strategies from our VyB Agency Click here

To follow our VyB Youtube Channel "What's the VyB?" Click here

Is there something fundamentally wrong with seeing what actually works in marketing?

Or is strategic pattern recognition somehow not valuable?

You decide what serves your success.

Unsubscribe | Update your profile

The Strategy Signal

Fractional CMOs and VP-level marketers get weekly strategic intelligence: winning campaign analysis through 3 AI models, cross-industry patterns, and 4-6 minute executive briefings that accelerate decision-making.

Read more from The Strategy Signal
Split image showing Duolingo's mascot death marketing campaign. Left side shows the green Duolingo owl (Duo) lying motionless with X's for eyes, appearing dead. Right side shows a gray, sad-looking owl with the text 'BRING BACK DUO' above it. Header text

Duolingo killed their mascot and made resurrection contingent on user behavior. You don’t need Super Bowl budgets when you can get your audience to do the work for you. Duolingo executed this entirely in-house (no marketing agency). Campaign ran February 11-25, 2025 - exactly 14 days. Team moved from concept to launch in just 6 days, avoiding typical agency delays that kill cultural relevance. The result? 1.7 billion impressions in two weeks. That’s twice the social conversation of the year’s...

How E.l.f.'s Comedy Special Cracked the Gen Z Health Message Code You can't lecture Gen Z into healthy behavior. But you can make them laugh their way into it. Their "Sunhinged" comedy special hit 10 million views in week one. 64% of Gen Zers often forget to apply sunscreen. 75% of Gen Z wants brands to "make them laugh." 90% of people are more likely to remember a funny ad. More importantly, it solved a problem every health brand faces. How do you get young people to care about boring but...

WhatsApp just turned their parent company's biggest weakness into marketing gold. While every tech company runs from privacy scandals, WhatsApp ran toward them. They made "we can't see your messages" the loudest promise in their marketing. The result? The biggest ad awareness jump of any UK brand in 2025. Research Intelligence 45 minutes dedicated multi-AI research ✅ 25+ sources across 3 AIs ✅ 12 primary company sources✅ 5 industry regions covered ✅ 8 cross-industry patterns confirmed THE...