Steal the "borrowed authenticity" framework Coke can't legally copy.


Hey! Here's a quick Intro.

It's been about 3 weeks now since we published last. Glad we can get back into it!

Liquid Death just made McDonald’s look expensive. They used a character made of toxic waste.

Think about that strategic choice.

A water brand partnered with a grotesque superhero. Peter Dinklage as The Toxic Avenger warned teens about soda dangers.

The campaign cost under $5 million total. The film made over $2 million box office. It hit #2 pre-orders in Cineverse history.

Meanwhile, Big Soda’s marketing teams watched from the sidelines. They couldn’t touch this strategy.

Research Intelligence

45 minutes dedicated multi-AI research

✅ 45 sources across 3 AIs
✅ 15 primary company sources
✅ 4 industry regions covered
✅ 8 cross-industry patterns confirmed

The Strategic Choice

Here’s what Liquid Death did differently. They turned a health message into cult entertainment.

video preview
Video: "The Toxic Avenger: Liquid Death Spokesperson" © Liquid Death (2025). Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rS8W5VRV5vc

Most brands lecture about sugar content. Liquid Death cast Peter Dinklage as The Toxic Avenger.

The character literally made of toxic waste warned kids about soda.

The irony was perfect. The timing was possibly...too good.

Like...bad good.

They launched August 19, 2025. The film hit theaters August 29.

Business Impact - Strategic Efficiency:

Cineverse executed acquisition, distribution, and all marketing for under $5 million total. Against this modest budget, the film generated $2 million box office revenue.

The campaign achieved #2 physical pre-order numbers in Cineverse history. Cineverse’s President called it “clearly the most profitable new film released that weekend.”

This represents total campaign performance; specific Liquid Death ROI and attribution methodology not publicly disclosed.

For strategic planning, consider this campaign correlation rather than confirmed causation.

Innovation Validation:

Liquid Death achieved $333 million revenue in 2024, up 26.6% year-over-year. Revenue represents company-level growth during campaign period.

The brand grew from $45 million (2021) to $263 million (2023). That’s 5× growth in two years. The company hit $1.4 billion valuation in March 2024.

They ran the PSA across digital, social, and Times Square billboards. The distribution hub lived at liquiddeath.com/toxicavenger.

The reality is simple: Coca-Cola and PepsiCo can’t copy this.

Their legal teams would never approve. Their brand safety reviews would kill it. Their mass-market positioning makes edgy moves impossible.

Liquid Death created a moat through irreverence. They own the space where healthy meets rebellious.

Legacy water brands emphasize purity and tranquility. Liquid Death uses demons, devils, and punk rock imagery.

The “Murder Your Thirst” tagline isn’t an accident.

The Transferable Pattern

“Borrowed Authenticity”

Partner with niche cultural assets.

Borrow their credibility, tone, and fanbase. Create content that feels like entertainment.

This works because modern consumers choose brands for culture first.

Product benefits come second.

Liquid Death proved water can feel as cool as craft beer.

The strategic exchange is simple. The brand gets cultural relevance it couldn’t build alone.

The IP owner gets exposure to aligned demographics. Both sides win.

What this means for you: stop building from scratch. Find cultural assets your audience already loves.

Make sure thematic alignment is perfect. Create content that rewards people for “getting the joke.”

The Toxic Avenger partnership worked perfectly.

video preview
Video: "The Toxic Avenger: Exclusive Red Band Trailer (2025)" © Legendary Entertainment/Troma Entertainment. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wki1V-Gxz6M

Both brands share toxicity themes. The names complement each other.

The audiences overlap completely.

Where This Pattern Wins

Here’s where else this works:

Old Spice

video preview

“The Man Your Man Could Smell Like” (2010)

Borrowed YouTube’s absurdist humor culture to shed the “old man” image.

Sales jumped 107% in one month. Became the #1 men’s body wash in the U.S.

Dollar Shave Club - Launch Video (2012):

video preview

Used raw, direct-to-camera YouTube creator aesthetic on a $4,500 budget.

Got 12,000 subscribers in 48 hours. Sold to Unilever for $1 billion four years later.

Poo-Pourri - “Girls Don’t Poop” (2013):

video preview

Subverted the prim British spokeswoman archetype with shocking frankness.

Generated 32 million views.

Created an entire product category through one viral video.

Strategic Durability

Bottom line: this approach works for 12-18 months minimum.

Cultural resonance beats massive media budgets.

Gen Z and Millennials reward entertainment over interruption.

What this means: early movers should act now. The novelty advantage won’t last forever.

More brands will copy this playbook. The bar for originality will rise.

Smart brands treat this as a core system. Not a one-off stunt.

Liquid Death has achieved exceptional growth. They scaled revenue from $45M in 2021 to an estimated $333M in 2024.

Thus reaching a $1.4B valuation by transforming commoditized water into a premium lifestyle brand through distinctive beer-can-like packaging and viral marketing.

The company has expanded beyond its original still water.

They went into sparkling, flavored varieties, iced teas, and hydration powders while maintaining consistent heavy metal branding, all sold at significant premiums ($1.50-2.00 per can versus generic water).

Their competitive advantage lies in generating organic viral attention. As opposed to relying on paid advertising.

They were effectively turning attention into a sustainable moat despite selling a commodity product.

That’s sustained performance, not viral luck.

Multi-LLM Insight Callout

All three AI models caught the same core pattern.

Entertainment-first marketing creates defensible competitive advantages.

ChatGPT focused on cultural timing and earned media.

Claude analyzed the challenger brand methodology.

Gemini mapped the “borrowed authenticity” framework.

The split revealed complementary insights on execution versus strategy.

PS - If you're looking for a deep dive...

  • See the raw multi-AI research and competitive analysis frameworks.
  • Get implementation playbooks that executives use to outmaneuver bigger competitors.
  • 6 Min Video Commentary and presentation - where I share my own thoughts on this trend
  • [Bonus] - a fully ready Client Strategy Presentation Deck on this topic (free download)

[Access the Strategic Deep-Dive →] Tons of reading + video commentary

Your Passionate Marketing Research Assistant

Matt Heyn
Point of Contact & Copywriter at VyB

When you're ready here are 2 ways I can help you:

  1. Main service for CMOs and Marketing Directors:

If you’re tired of:

  • Managing 5 vendors when what you really need is an All-in-One Turn-Key Agency

Grab one of the remaining spots now for a free discovery call.

If you don't get 3 actionable insights on your brand story or business, I'll connect you with another agency that can.

No pitching, no sales call. Just auditing your business and providing 3 insights.

2. Need Inspiration?

For weekly LinkedIn videos and posts on copywriting and marketing strategies from our VyB Agency Click here

To follow our VyB Youtube Channel "What's the VyB?" Click here

Is there something fundamentally wrong with seeing what actually works in marketing?

Or is strategic pattern recognition somehow not valuable?

You decide what serves your success.

Unsubscribe | Update your profile

The Strategy Signal

Fractional CMOs and VP-level marketers get weekly strategic intelligence: winning campaign analysis through 3 AI models, cross-industry patterns, and 4-6 minute executive briefings that accelerate decision-making.

Read more from The Strategy Signal
Split image showing Duolingo's mascot death marketing campaign. Left side shows the green Duolingo owl (Duo) lying motionless with X's for eyes, appearing dead. Right side shows a gray, sad-looking owl with the text 'BRING BACK DUO' above it. Header text

Duolingo killed their mascot and made resurrection contingent on user behavior. You don’t need Super Bowl budgets when you can get your audience to do the work for you. Duolingo executed this entirely in-house (no marketing agency). Campaign ran February 11-25, 2025 - exactly 14 days. Team moved from concept to launch in just 6 days, avoiding typical agency delays that kill cultural relevance. The result? 1.7 billion impressions in two weeks. That’s twice the social conversation of the year’s...

How E.l.f.'s Comedy Special Cracked the Gen Z Health Message Code You can't lecture Gen Z into healthy behavior. But you can make them laugh their way into it. Their "Sunhinged" comedy special hit 10 million views in week one. 64% of Gen Zers often forget to apply sunscreen. 75% of Gen Z wants brands to "make them laugh." 90% of people are more likely to remember a funny ad. More importantly, it solved a problem every health brand faces. How do you get young people to care about boring but...

WhatsApp just turned their parent company's biggest weakness into marketing gold. While every tech company runs from privacy scandals, WhatsApp ran toward them. They made "we can't see your messages" the loudest promise in their marketing. The result? The biggest ad awareness jump of any UK brand in 2025. Research Intelligence 45 minutes dedicated multi-AI research ✅ 25+ sources across 3 AIs ✅ 12 primary company sources✅ 5 industry regions covered ✅ 8 cross-industry patterns confirmed THE...